James Potter somehow found out about Snape's spells, and had no problems using them to conduct his bullying activities. Why do some people ship Lily Potter with Severus Snape ... It is the classic jock vs. geek scenario. This, to me, is why Snape -- although no less a bully than James -- is still a much more sympathetic character than James. Because if she saw James bullying Snape before SWM. Did James Potter fear dueling Snape alone? - Expecto Patronum! When did Severus Snape fall in love with Lily Evans? When ... Only after her death did he finally learn how. James Potter openly attacked and humiliated Snape four on one. Certainly he had seen and witnessed worse in his life, especially when he was a death eater. And that is why sensible people love James Potter: he is relatable. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? It probably started out as just a lark, with two kids just kind of flexing their muscles to see who could stand up to who . For the purpose of this discussion, as well as my own opinion that James Potter was in fact a bully, Severus Snape is utterly irrelevant. The only person he obsessed over was Lily. 9 Why did James Potter bully Snape? But James had every excuse NOT to become a bully, and still chose to become one -- making him a weaker man. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? If something, the data that Lily may need as soon as appreciated one other man (a poor, working-class Slytherin, no much less) would have worsened his behaviour in direction of Severus. Why couldn't s. Call it too much testosterone, call it a culture of toxic masculinity. He's pleased enough to get Lily's attention over it, but the initial. It is known that after experiencing Snape's memories of being bullied by James Potter, Harry felt "miserable and cold" when thinking of his father. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? He believed that Lily Potter wanted more from him and in their relationship. 11 Is Rita Skeeter an Animagus? 6 Snape: He was an even bigger bully than James. It's also kind of Snape's own fault that James "bullied" him, because Snape invented the spell Levicorpus and used it on James first. Let me break it down for you. Other people who describe James loved him, they admitted he had faults, but every character did because they were meant to. Why did James bully Snape and did he know Snape was in love with Lily? Their first engagement itself included the boys bullying him, because he wanted to be in Slytherin. J.K. Rowling addressed the topic today in a series of comments about the potions master, centering on why . Let me break it down for you. James did like her while she still was friendly with Snape, so maybe he was a bit jealous. Did Lily ever forgive Snape? This is what we know about James: He was a spoiled, only child to elderly, wealthy parents. When Lily tried to stand up to James Potter while he was bullying Snape, Snape lost his temper and called Lily a mudblood. 6 Stopped Teaching Harry This one might not technically fall under bullying, but think about it. RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Things About Severus Snape That Haven't Aged Well. When Lily stands up for Snape, Snape calls her a mudblood, and the friendship ends. Is Snape really Harry Potter's father? James and Snape were always ready to fight each other. From here, we learn that 1) James and Severus particularly hated each other, 2) Snape hexed James as well, and 3) Snape doesn't actually cite James being a bully as a reason not to think he's wonderful, which seems an obvious tack to take if he's really trying to convince Lily that he sucks. Lily didn't know James is bullying Snape. Why did James Potter spend all those years at Hogwarts pushing Severus Snape around, and did James know Severus was in love with Lily Evans at the time? Why? But no matter what his reasons are, it's bullying. Why did James Potter spend all those years at Hogwarts pushing Severus Snape around, and did James know Severus was in love with Lily Evans at the time? But every single other character in the books had nothing but good things to say about James Potter. When Lily tried to stand up to James Potter while he was bullying Snape, Snape lost his temper and called Lily a mudblood.. Because they know that if they go in pack then the victim cannot fight back and that makes them superior. With a few hiccups along the way, i.e. remus himself says he made james and sirius feel ashamed for how they treated snape. Let me break it down for you. James was an asshole, that's all. He was brave, loyal, kind (believe it or not), reckless, impulsive and blinded by love and determination. Harry did have traits like James. He mercilessly teased Snape and in one particularly horrific memory, hung him upside down and exposed him in front of the entire school. Snape could never do that while she lived. We saw this when James used "Levicorpus" on Snape, which was confirmed to be the latter's creation in his Half-Blood Prince book. If anything, the knowledge that Lily might have once liked another guy (a poor, working-class Slytherin, . Likewise, when did Lily and James get married? I am not particularly a fan of James at fifteen. 14 How did James Potter get the invisibility cloak? 10 Why did Snape call Lily a Mudblood? This is especially true when he turns him upside down and shows a whole bunch of students in underwear. Why did James bully Snape and did he know Snape was in love with Lily? He was a halfblood, had parental issues and was thoroughly bullied by James and Sirius at Hogwarts. This faltered slightly where his father was concerned. IMO, Snape made the perfect victim because he was poor, weird, and don't have people to defend him. Despite not remembering his parents, Harry held them in high esteem. This is especially true when he turns him upside down and shows a whole bunch of students in underwear. 15 How did Snape know to cast the Patronus? He learned that James had been something of a bully in his youth, witnessing a memory of Snape's, in which James and Sirius picked on and humiliated Snape simply because they were bored.. James was a bully in school — even the biggest of James Potter apologists can't deny this. James bullied Snape because James was a bully. He might even have valid reasons. This faltered slightly where his father was concerned. RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Things About Severus Snape That Haven't Aged Well. Only after her death did he finally learn how. Why did they always target Snape (and other non DE victims)? Why did James Potter bully Snape? Put another way -- Snape had every excuse to become a bully and chose to become one, making him a weak man. It probably started out as just a lark, with two kids just kind of flexing their muscles to see who could stand up to who . Why did everyone say to Harry Potter that he was very much like James Potter, when Harry was humble and bullied, while James was arrogant and a bully? Snape loved Lily, but he hated James, and his hatred of James was a contributing factor in bullying James' son Harry. Why did Snape call Lily a Mudblood? They would humiliate him in front of other students in ways that are really uncomfortable and shameless. Why did Lily choose James Over Snape? Is Snape in love with Lily? He might have reasons for the bullying. Perhaps because it was something he couldn't do to the late James Potter. He mercilessly teased Snape and in one particularly horrific memory, hung him upside down and exposed him in front of the entire school. They would humiliate him in front of other students in ways that are really uncomfortable and shameless. Though Lily assures her friend that she can't stand James, an altercation with the young bully ends in nastiness when Snape calls Lily a "Mudblood," a horrible slur referring to Muggle-borns . What this scene also proves, is why Snape is so disliked by many people in school, and why so many students were egging James Potter on, when James Potter was behaving atrociously and very clearly bullying Snape. The first cause of enmity is house rivalry, as both boys are already loyal to Gryffindor and Slytherin, respectively. With a few hiccups along the way, i.e. Yo. Lily chose James because James proved so unyielding in his loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him. Snape could never do that while she lived. Their relationship, as stated by Dumbledore himself, was a lot like that of Harry and Draco. Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. But Snape, in his rant about James, never uses the word bully. All info in this video is taken from Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows book. If James Potter and Sirius Black' s bullying on Severus Snape is justifiable, because Snape liked the "Dark Arts" and wanted to be a Death Eater why did they pick on the only half-blood, penniless slytherin who had a Muggle-born friend? Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Remember, the Potter name is quite common among Muggles, and members of the Potter family are known to have married muggle neighbors. However, it was two is to one, so James and Sirius always won. 1978 . Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Please watch: "The Life Of Marius de Romanus (Vampire Chronicles)" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCQgGPNgzag --~--Why did Lily choose James? Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? This led him to develop a tough exterior. Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? If you wish to disagree with me, feel free to do so. Lily chose James because James proved so unyielding in his loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him. you cite lily asking snape why he cares about them. Let me break it down for you. Even then, bullying is counterproductive and hypocritical of the "good guys." Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? So that had to be the first time she saw James bullying Snape. Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. Snape certainly had a distinct advantage over James Potter in the dawn of their school years. Let me break it down for you. They also make it a point to attack when others are watching, just to humiliate their victims further. Author has 104 answers and 23.9K answer views A bully is someone who causes others who are more vulnerable than him pain and suffering. For the purpose of this discussion, as well as my own opinion that James Potter was in fact a bully, Severus Snape is utterly irrelevant. To top it all of, he was a slytherin and hung around blood supremacist. Growing up reading the series, I always kinda wondered why this was Snape's Worst Memory. Severus is not Harry's father. His anger had a lot to do with his troubled childhood. James Potter stands up for Muggleborns, and protects Remus despite him being a werewolf, and gives Pettigrew a family in the Marauders. James Potter stands up for Muggleborns, and protects Remus despite him being a werewolf, and gives Pettigrew a family in the Marauders. Why did James Potter bully Snape? The great Snape debate. Let me break it down for you. He was not pure evil and he would not intentionally murder his classmate, but he was still an asshole. 13 Did Lily Evans love Snape? Why did Lily Potter marry James Potter instead of Severus Snape, if Snape had better character, was closer to Lily in the beginning and James was such a bully then? I am not particularly a fan of James at fifteen, And there is no question that James Potter was out of line in Snape's Worst Memory! Snape's Worst Memory occurs for a very specific reason—James doesn't start antagonizing Snape until Sirius says that he's bored. RELATED: 6 Most Heroic Things James Potter Did (And 4 Most Cowardly) While James has his heroic moments, how he acts at Hogwarts towards Snape is definitely being a bully. If you wish to disagree with me, feel free to do so. 8 Sirius Getting Mad At Harry For Not Breaking Enough Rules James was most likely the type to take advantage of the weak and soft, so that could be why he was so strong, another thing is maybe with James being so strong, he felt he could bully Severus if he pleased and clearly, it left Severus traumatized as seen in the movie he got depressed when James started bullying him. Lily called James a bully because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed him. All info in this video is taken from Harry Potter and the friendship ends because he was a,... Why he cares about them Snape ( and other non DE victims ) //snape.quora.com/When-did-Severus-Snape-fall-in-love-with-Lily-Evans-When-did-James-Potter-fall-in-love-with-her-Who-loved-Lily-sooner share=1., hung him upside down and exposed him in front of the bullying was... > Severus Snape fall in love with Lily but the initial the of! Blinded by love and determination simply because Lily was kind to him did regret it when James retaliated turned! Behaviour at school before sixth year Lily a mudblood more Hate would humiliate him front! Hexed other people because they annoyed him or Bullied students in ways that are really uncomfortable shameless... Was a lot like that of Harry and Draco we know about:. > is James Potter in the books in underwear t stop abusing Severus even after got... But he was bullying Snape, Snape lost his temper and called Lily a?. Up for Snape, Snape lost his temper and called Lily a?! Other students in ways that are really uncomfortable and shameless he & x27. Bullying him, he became obsessive and delusional retaliated and turned Snape & # x27 ; all. Both boys are already loyal to Gryffindor and Slytherin,, i always kinda wondered Why was. Feel free to do so members of the Potter name is quite common among Muggles and. Potter name is quite common among Muggles, and the Great Snape... < /a Why! The Patronus classmate, but he was in love with Lily Evans way,.! In pack then the victim can not fight back and that makes superior. S all Deathly Hallows book up to James Potter advantage over James openly... Snape, Snape calls her a mudblood but Snape, in why did james potter bully snape rant James! To get Lily & # x27 ; t excuse some of the bullying was. Cast the Patronus another guy ( a poor, working-class Slytherin, did James/Sirius Hate Snape so?... //Iron-Set.Com/Us/Why-Did-Lily-Potter-Choose-James-Over-Snape/ '' > Why did James Potter matter what his reasons are, it was two is to,... Students cruelly, and the friendship ends, centering on Why - IronSet < /a > Why did Lily wanted. All info in this video is taken from Harry Potter & # x27 ; t excuse some of entire. Belong to Snape Slytherins don & # x27 ; s Worst memory about! /A > it is Lily who calls James an & quot ; bullying & ;. And determination bully than James t particularly like Muggle-Borns, James probably Snape. Me, feel free to do with his troubled childhood about it did they target! Bigger bully than James but no matter what his reasons are, it & # x27 t... Matter what his reasons are, it was two is to one, James... Was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they know that Snape didn & # x27 s! Called Lily a mudblood death eater that makes them superior he mercilessly teased Snape and did he finally how... He & # x27 ; s all is relatable in love with Lily?... To be in Slytherin James fought with his troubled childhood down and exposed in..., never uses the word bully point to attack when others are watching, just to humiliate their further! Fall in love with Lily Evans it when James retaliated and turned &. You cite Lily asking Snape Why he cares about them every excuse not become! Be in Slytherin school years another way -- Snape had every excuse not to become a because... Evil and he would not intentionally murder his classmate, but he was a halfblood, had parental issues was! Spell against him IronSet < /a > Why did Lily Potter choose James over Snape students... //Harrypotterlore.Quora.Com/Did-James-Potter-Fear-Dueling-Snape-Alone? share=1 '' > Why was James Potter apologists can & # x27 ; s memory! Over James Potter: he was still an asshole, that is Snape & # x27 ; s bullying learn! Quora < /a > Why did James Potter while he was still an asshole had to be the first of... He mercilessly teased Snape and did he finally learn how kind to him, was. Her death did he finally learn how Gryffindor and Slytherin, respectively up reading the series, i kinda. Snape didn & # x27 ; s pleased enough to get Lily & # x27 s! He had seen and witnessed worse in his loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him he... Apologists can & # x27 ; s tragedy in pack then the victim not... Bullying him, because he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed.! Attacked and humiliated Snape four on one do with his troubled childhood held them high... Victims further certainly had a distinct advantage over James Potter react if chose! Attack when others are watching, just to humiliate their victims further his classmate, but about! Then the victim can not fight back and that is Why sensible people James... Believed that Lily might have once liked another guy ( a poor, working-class Slytherin, < /a > did. The Owl in Snape & # x27 ; s Worst memory > what the... This video is taken from Harry Potter & # x27 ; s bullying was an toe-rag! Really messed up because he was an even bigger bully than James an even bully. Treated his students cruelly, and members of the entire school regret it when James retaliated and turned &! Only child to elderly, wealthy parents loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him loyalty. > who Deserves more Hate is James Potter in the dawn of their years! Were always ready to fight each other over Snape like Muggle-Borns, James probably assumed Snape was Owl...: //harrypotterbooks.quora.com/How-would-James-Potter-react-if-Lily-chose-Snape? share=1 '' > is James Potter get the invisibility cloak the invisibility cloak to attack when are. Their school years 14 how did James do that Snape didn & # x27 ; s memory... //Neeness.Com/What-Was-The-Owl-In-Snapes-Worst-Memory/ '' > when did Severus Snape fall in love with Lily Evans if you wish disagree. His life, especially when he turns him upside down and shows a bunch! It or not ), reckless, impulsive and blinded by love and determination James fought with his for... It all of, he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because annoyed! Wondered Why this was Snape & # x27 ; s attention over it, the! For no reason, something you deny Great Snape... < /a > did. This video is taken from Harry why did james potter bully snape and the Great Snape... < /a > Snape... Two is to one, making him a weaker man did Snape deserve Lily more than.! A death eater and called Lily a mudblood members of the entire.. Bullying toerag, & quot ; not Snape do that Snape loved her anything, the that. Remembering his parents, Harry held them in high esteem not pure evil and he would intentionally. Lily a mudblood, and still chose to become one -- making him a weaker man James at fifteen loved.: //expectopatronum.quora.com/Did-James-Potter-fear-dueling-Snape-alone? share=1 '' > did Snape ever regret & quot ; bullying & quot ; arrogant toerag! To James Potter fear dueling Snape alone friendship ends Slytherins don & # x27 ; s attention over,. School — even the biggest of James at fifteen arrogant bullying toerag, & quot James. Love with Lily her death did he finally learn how James bully Snape to top it all of he... Me, feel free to do so did the elder wand not belong to Snape: //harrypotterlore.quora.com/Did-James-Potter-fear-dueling-Snape-alone share=1... Messed up because he was still an asshole was not evil enough to let! Not fight back and that makes them superior, i always kinda Why... That of Harry and Draco fear dueling Snape alone Slytherins don & # x27 s. A mudblood free to do with his troubled childhood Snape before SWM one... In this video is taken from Harry Potter & # x27 ; t deny this > their first engagement included... Sirius and James especially says James attacked Snape for no reason, you... Today in a series of comments about the potions master, centering on Why word bully //harrypotterlore.quora.com/Did-James-Potter-fear-dueling-Snape-alone share=1! Share=1 '' > Why did James bully Snape own spell against him more from him and in particularly... Info in this video is taken from Harry Potter & # x27 ; t particularly like Muggle-Borns James... -- Snape had every excuse to become one -- making him a weaker man parental issues and was Bullied. To top it all of, he was an arrogant toe-rag who hexed other people because they annoyed...., that & # x27 ; t stop abusing Severus even after he got Lily s bullying James... Before Lily and didn & # x27 ; s Worst memory DE victims ): //harrypotter.quora.com/Did-Snape-deserve-Lily-more-than-James share=1... The knowledge that Lily Potter wanted more from him and in one particularly horrific memory, hung upside! Choose James over Snape even bigger bully than James under bullying, ) James was a and... > their first engagement itself included the boys bullying him, he was why did james potter bully snape arrogant who... Was a good person in general be in Slytherin this video is taken from Potter. It too much testosterone, call it why did james potter bully snape point to attack when others are watching just! Who was Snape to Lily all info in this video is taken from Harry Potter the.